"Walking along the beach at dawn, ______" Which ending conforms to Standard English: (A) a rare shell was found by the children, or (B) the children found a rare shell?
- The opening phrase "Walking along the beach at dawn" has no subject of its own.
- The noun right after the comma must be whoever was walking.
- In (A) that noun is "a rare shell," and a shell cannot walk. In (B) it is "the children."
Answer: (B) the children found a rare shell.