Leadership and management: leadership style

Psychology A2 · Organisational Psychology. The idea in plain words, the rules to remember, the mistake to avoid and a worked example, written and checked by Mega Lecture.

Test this topic freeAll Psychology A2 topics

The idea

Muczyk and Reimann describe leader behaviour using two questions. Who makes the decision: the leader alone (autocratic) or with the staff (democratic)? How closely is the work then supervised: closely (directive) or loosely (permissive)? Combining them gives four styles.

Scouller says leadership works at three levels: public (leading the group), private (leading individuals one to one) and personal (the leader's own skills, attitudes and self-mastery).

Research on gender suggests that women tend to lead more democratically, and that a woman using a 'masculine' style may be judged harshly because it clashes with stereotypes (role congruity). Cuadrado et al. (2008) tested this idea in Spain.

Rules to remember

Common mistake

Students mix up the two dimensions. 'Autocrat or democrat' is about who makes the decision; 'directive or permissive' is about how closely the work is supervised afterwards. Also remember that Cuadrado et al. did not support the prediction that female leaders would be rated worse.

Worked example

A head chef asks the whole kitchen team to vote on the new menu. Once it is chosen, each cook prepares the dishes in his or her own way with no checking. Which of Muczyk and Reimann's styles is this?

  1. Decision: the team takes part through a vote, so the style is democratic, not autocratic.
  2. Carrying it out: there is no close supervision, so the style is permissive, not directive.
  3. Put the two together.

Answer: Permissive democrat.

Ask about this

Type what you are stuck on. The helper finds the explanation, worked examples and the notes to read, free and instant.

Keep going

← Leadership and management: traditional and modern theoriesLeadership and management: leaders and followers →Take a Psychology A2 test